A determination of whether the existence of moral dilemma pose a challenge to utilitarianism

Similarly, public officials can and should be partial to people in the jurisdiction in which they work. Just how much weight does the agent-centered prerogative give to personal projects. The rules of the road do not tell drivers when to drive or what their destination should be for example.

This widely reprinted article, though it does not focus on utilitarianism, uses utilitarian reasoning and has sparked decades of debate about moral demandingness and moral impartiality. Their suffering does not matter morally.


If our aim is always to produce the best results, it seems plausible to think that in each case of deciding what is the right thing to do, we should consider the available options i. Anyways, this text does not aim to solve the problem of inescapable moral wrongdoing, but just to draw some attention on it.

From a Humean perspective, whatever security they might amass in the form of possessions or find in the form of fame see Hume [], —24it cannot protect them from death. According to this line of argument, then, there is nothing mysterious or complicated about a country's right to screen applicants for admission: Like feudal birthrights privileges, restrictive citizenship is hard to justify when one thinks about it closely.

The concept of slave morality comes from the philosopher Frederick Nietzsche, who held that oppressed peoples tend to develop moral theories that reaffirm subservient traits as virtues. Though Mill does not treat secondary principles as mere rules of thumb in utilitarian calculation, he does not think that they should be followed uncritically or independently of their consequences.

There are many possible courses of action he could take, but under his moral theory of choice, no option seems to be void of moral violation.

Act and Rule Utilitarianism

If so, then there are interesting and difficult questions about how long and under what conditions one can work in a foreign country without the standard rights and privileges of equal citizenship before one becomes objectionably treated as a political subordinate.

While it may be true, it may also be false, and if it is false, then utilitarians must acknowledge that intentionally punishing an innocent person could sometimes be morally justified. Mill was raised in the tradition of Philosophical Radicalism, made famous by Jeremy Bentham —John Austin —and his father James Mill —which applied utilitarian principles in a self-conscious and systematic way to issues of institutional design and social reform.

And given this, what justification could the Swedes have for putting guns at their borders to deter Chadians from trying to move north and take advantage of the preferable social, political and economic environment. If a country's exploding population were free to move anywhere in the world, for instance, then its citizens would not bear the full costs of population growth and would therefore be that much more resistant to laws designed to limit the number of children born.

Given that democracy's principal virtue is thought to be its connection to self-determination, democrats often favor bounded groups which enjoy dominion over their own affairs.

For instance, reformist utilitarians, such as Peter Singerhave argued that utilitarianism entails extensive duties of mutual aid that would call for significant changes in the lifestyles of all those who are even moderately well off.

We could reconcile either hedonism or perfectionism with the desire-satisfaction claim if we treat the latter as a metaethical claim about what makes good things good and the former as a substantive claim about what things are good.

Mill's Moral and Political Philosophy

Insofar as Mill does discuss subjective pleasures, he is not clear which, if either, of these conceptions of pleasure he favors. Because it makes the optimal obligatory and the suboptimal wrong, it appears to expand the domain of the forbidden, collapse the distinction between the permissible and the obligatory, and make no room for the supererogatory.

This prediction, however, is precarious. Justice involves duties that are perfect duties—that is, duties that are correlated with rights V The reason for this is that the practice of promise-keeping is a very valuable.

The ethical framework of utilitarianism explains that the determination of whether or not consequences and actions should be considered as ethical is based on their ability to bring the maximum amount of good to the greatest number of individuals (Arnold, Beauchamp, & Bowie.



Utilitarianism and consequentialism are completely independent theories. d. Utilitarianism and consequentialism are inconsistent. Most utilitarians deny the existence of moral knowledge.

The goodness of the intentions of the person performing the action. d. Whether or not the action violates God's commands. The Roots of Morality Maxine Sheets-Johnstone “This innovative and clearly written book is a significant contribution to the philosophy of the body, to ethics, and to phenomenology.” —Robert P.

- The tension between eudaimonist or otherwise natural ethics and the ethics of divine command goes back to Plato’s Euthyphro, where we ask whether right is right because the God says so, or if God says so because it is right (philosophers sometimes call this the Euthyphro dilemma).

Thus, even if some women identify with care ethics, it is unclear whether this is a general quality of women, whether moral development is distinctly and dualistically gendered, and whether the voice of care is the only alternative moral voice.

Feb 26,  · Moral dilemmas are a central topic in moral philosophy. Much of this attention is due to the fact that they are always connected to some polemic and interesting discussion involving Ethics. Practical examples of moral dilemmas abound. Discussions about abortion, euthanasia, animal rights, are some of these examples.

A determination of whether the existence of moral dilemma pose a challenge to utilitarianism
Rated 4/5 based on 44 review
Moral Dilemmas and Inescapable Moral Wrongdoing | Practical Ethics